Online Presence For Local Businesses - Tips from MM
- Colby Barnhouse

- Apr 11
- 3 min read
Updated: Apr 19
You look at your business and think, "We’re doing everything right, so why isn’t it growing?" The truth is uncomfortable but clear: you’re not losing because your business is bad. You’re losing because your
online presence is forgettable. In today’s world, forgettable means invisible. People don’t give you a chance anymore. They decide quickly whether to trust you or move on.
People Decide Before They Call
Before a potential customer picks up the phone, they’ve already made a mental decision. They search for you online, visit your website, and scroll through your social media. In about 10 seconds, they decide if they trust you or keep looking. That’s all the time you get to make an impression.
Why Most Businesses Miss the Mark
It’s not because they don’t care. It’s because they don’t understand what really matters online. Here are the common pitfalls:
Your Website Isn’t Closing Visitors
Your website might look decent, but does it do the job? Ask yourself:
Does it clearly explain what you do within seconds?
Does it build confidence in your business?
Does it encourage visitors to take action, like calling or signing up?
If the answer is no, your website is just a placeholder. It’s not working to bring in customers.
Your Online Presence as a Local Business Feels Dead
If your last post was weeks ago, you don’t look busy or trustworthy. Instead, you look like a risk. People avoid risks when choosing a business. Active, engaging content shows you’re alive and ready to serve.
You Blend In With Everyone Else
Using the same messaging as your competitors, sharing safe, generic content, and saying “we offer great service” doesn’t pull people toward you. It makes you forgettable. People move on to the next option.
What You Really Need to Win Customers
You don’t need more traffic. You need a reason for people to choose you when they find you. People are already searching for services like yours. The problem is you’re not winning their trust or attention.
Here’s what actually works:
A website that grabs attention immediately and clearly states what you do
Content that shows you’re active, engaged, and trustworthy
Messaging that makes people think, “This is the one I want to work with”
When these elements are in place, you stop chasing customers. Instead, they come to you.
How to Fix Your Online Presence
Make Your Website Work Harder
Your website should do more than look good. It should:
Communicate your value clearly in the first few seconds
Use simple language that anyone can understand
Include strong calls to action, like “Call now” or “Get a free quote”
Show testimonials or proof of your work to build trust
For example, a local landscaping company improved their website by adding before-and-after photos and clear service descriptions. Their calls increased by 40% within two months.
Keep Your Social Media Alive and Engaging
Post regularly to show you’re active. Share:
Behind-the-scenes looks at your work
Customer stories or reviews
Tips related to your industry
Updates about your business
Consistency builds trust. A bakery that posted daily photos of fresh bread and customer favorites saw a 25% increase in foot traffic.
Stand Out With Unique Messaging
Avoid generic phrases like “we offer great service.” Instead, focus on what makes you different:
Do you offer faster delivery?
Do you use eco-friendly materials?
Do you have a unique process or guarantee?
Highlight these points clearly on your website and social media. Make it easy for people to see why you’re the best choice.

People Are Choosing Every Day.
Are They Choosing You?
Every day, people search, compare, and decide. The question is: are they choosing your business or skipping it? If your online presence as a local business i
s forgettable, they will skip you.
You can change that by making your website and social media work for you. Show that you’re active, trustworthy, and different. Give people a reason to choose you.
If you want to know exactly where you’re losing customers online, let's get a review of
your website and social media. Find out what’s holding you back and how to fix it.
No pressure, just clear advice.




Comments